September 27, 2007
-- Current and former downtown-development officials
launched a bitter battle of words yesterday over
whether warnings about safety concerns at the former
Deutsche Bank building were ignored before two
firefighters were killed there.
The former official
in charge of dismantling the contaminated tower at
the World Trade Center site said he was berated by
his ex-boss, Avi Schick, chairman of the Lower
Manhattan Development Corp., for talking about
safety.
Charles Maikish, the
ex-director of the Lower Manhattan Construction
Command Center, said that in an early-June meeting,
Schick rebuffed any attempts to discuss a May 25
memo Maikish wrote warning that the demolition
contractors were not subjected to proper oversight.
Instead, Schick
ripped into Maikish for penning the alarming memo,
said Maikish spokesman Ken Frydman. "[Schick]
asked, 'Why did you send the memo?' [Maikish] said
because it was important to document these issues
and he put it in memo form for the key players,"
Frydman said. "Schick apparently wasn't happy
and let him know as much. He went so far as to say,
according to Charlie, that he can't wait until July
15," Frydman said.
Maikish had
previously announced that would be his last day as
head of the LMCCC. Through his spokesman,
Errol Cockfield, Schick insisted the meeting never
happened. Schick also said that neither he nor
any other of the four LMDC officials who were sent
copies of the memo got it.
David Emil, president
of the LMDC, along with board members Robert
Douglass, Carl Weisbrod and Deputy Mayor Dan
Doctoroff, were all sent copies of the memo, Frydman
said.
As The Post reported
yesterday, the memo, written a week after a pipe
fell from the building onto the Engine 10 firehouse
below, voiced concerns that his agency could not
"safely or efficiently" manage the demolition
because it lacked two supervisors to oversee the
contractors. The memo was delivered by a
messenger service and there are documents proving
receipt, Frydman said.
The opposite accounts
of what may or may not have transpired indicate
growing worries about the ongoing criminal
investigation into the fire. Investigators
from the Manhattan District Attorney's Office are
probing the Aug. 18 blaze that killed firefighters
Joseph Graffagnino and Robert Beddia on the 14th
floor of the burning building. The building's
standpipe, which that was supposed to supply water,
was broken, allowing the fire to rage out of
control.
The main contractors
on the job, Bovis Lend Lease and John Galt Corp.,
had been cited for numerous safety violations, and
investigators are looking to see what role, if any,
the companies played in allowing the standpipe to
fall into disrepair.
Maikish's memo asked for more resources to manage
the demolition.
Frydman said Bob
Harvey, Maikish's former deputy who replaced him in
July, helped draft the memo. In a statement
yesterday, Harvey denied ever knowing about the
memo. Adding to the confusion, Cockfield said
the only meeting Schick had with Maikish in early
June was to discuss a multimillion-dollar publicity
campaign for the LMCCC.
cbennett@nypost.com